Residents divided on Obamacare decision

There is mixed reaction locally to the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision Thursday to uphold President Barack Obama’s health care law.

The nine Supreme Court justices were tasked with deciding if the Affordable Care Act, passed in 2010, was constitutional. The vote was close, passing by a 5-4 ruling.

At the heart of the debate is the question of whether or not it is constitutional for the government to force individuals to purchase health insurance.

The Supreme Court determined it is constitutional to do so, as long as the penalty for not purchasing health insurance is a tax.

Sen. John Proos, R-St. Joseph, said the court’s ruling sets a dangerous precedent.

“I think it is a very concerning precedent where the federal government, or government in general, can impose a tax for the purpose of compelling an individual to act … by virtue of their pocketbook or to act in a manner the government deems fit,” he said.

U.S. Rep. Fred Upton, R-St. Joseph, disagreed with the court’s ruling, saying in a released statement the law is unaffordable, unworkable and must be repealed.

“One of the mistakes of Obamacare was that it tried to fix every problem in the health care system with one massive new law crafted in Washington,” Upton said.

“And we ended up with an unpopular and unworkable law because its authors failed to listen to the American people and failed to address the most pressing challenge to our health care system in rising costs.”

Rep. Sharon Tyler, R-Niles, joined Proos and Upton in speaking against the court’s ruling.

Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich., and Sen. Carl Levin, D-Mich., were in favor of the decision.

The law contains several provisions, including one prohibiting insurers from denying coverage to people with pre-existing conditions and another allowing children to remain on their family policy until age 26.

It also allows for the expansion of Medicaid, provides tax credits to small businesses that provide health insurance and limits the amount of money insurance companies can spend on overhead, salaries and marketing, according to John Freeman, director of Know Your Care Michigan. Businesses can also be fined for not providing health coverage for employees.

The law takes full effect in 2014.

Chief Justice John Roberts and justices Sonia Sotomayor, Stephen Breyer, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Elena Kagan ruled in favor of the health care law. Justices Anthony Kennedy, Samuel Alito, Antonin Scalia and Clarence Thomas were dissenting.

Here’s a small portion of what local politicians had to say about Thursday’s ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court to uphold President Obama’s health care law:

Rep. Sharon Tyler, R-Niles:

“I’m extremely disappointed with the Court’s decision. I believe that health care decisions should be an individual choice between a patient and a doctor, without the federal government interfering. I also believe that tax hikes are not the answer as many middle-class families in Michigan were already struggling to make ends meet even before this ruling.”

Sen. John Proos, R-St. Joseph:

“I think it is a very concerning precedent where the federal government or government in general can impose a tax for the purpose of compelling an individual to act, compelling an individual to act by virtue of their pocketbook or to act in a manner the government deems fit.”

Sen. Debbie Stabenow, D-Mich.:

“Today the Supreme Court upheld important protections for Michigan families, including lower prescription drug prices for seniors, access to maternity care and mammograms for women, tools for Michigan small businesses to lower their health care costs, and coverage for children with preexisting conditions.”

U.S. Rep. Fred Upton, R-Mich.:

“One of the mistakes of Obamacare was that it tried to fix every problem in the health care system with one massive new law crafted in Washington. And we ended up with an unpopular and unworkable law because its authors failed to listen to the American people and failed to address the most pressing challenge to our health care system in rising costs.”

Sen. Carl Levin, D-Mich.:

“Today’s Supreme Court ruling is an important step toward universal health care coverage, which is long overdue. It ensures that millions of Americans who have health insurance will be more able to depend on their coverage without fear of losing it to the whims of an insurance company. I have always believed in the law’s ability to make a real and positive difference in peoples’ lives, and I’m gratified that the court’s decision protects the interests of American families who have so much to gain from health insurance reform.”

Business

Mno-Bmadsen acquires OJS Building Services, Inc.

Berrien County

South Bend woman gets prison time for role in Buchanan, Niles robberies

Berrien County

Berrien County Treasurer launches re-election bid

Buchanan

Buchanan mayor to face recall vote

Cass County

Two vehicle accident sends one to the hospital in Porter Township

Community News

Niles pastor celebrates 40th pastoral anniversary

Community News

Edwardsburg to host final bond proposal open house Monday

Business

Creekside Greenhouse, Art and a Suit open for business

Business

Cassopolis set to host 2024 Beach Bash

Cass County

Cass County to pursue drug enforcement, senior services millage renewals

Cassopolis

Cass County celebrates Day of Prayer at ACTION Ministries

Community News

Taking the stage: Niles natives to star in A&A Ballet’s ‘Cinderella’

Community News

SMC graduates 17-member nursing class

Brandywine Education

Brandywine bond proposal election Tuesday

Leader Columnists

Cains: Opinion is not news

Crime/Court

Niles man gets probation for sending explicit photo to minor

Community News

Dowagiac, Edwardsburg drama programs nominated for WAVE Awards

Business

Zolman Tire hosts Student Leadership Award ceremony

Columns

APPLEGATE: Providing a comprehensive and accessible learning environment for all students

Crime/Court

Niles man gets prison time on drug charges

Community News

AMVETS Post 1978 hosts annual Blessing of the Bikes event

Letters to the Editor

Vote ‘yes’ May 7 for Bobcats

Business

JC’s Grill opens in Niles Township

Cass County

Cass County high school students invited to participate in design contest