pittsstar"Fear is the most powerful enemy of reason. Both fear and reason are essential to human survival, but the relationship between them is unbalanced. Reason may sometimes dissipate fear, but fear frequently shuts down reason." - from "The Assault on Reason" by Al Gore

Archived Story

Leonard Pitts: Lacking facts and reason, health-care foes use fear

Published 10:52am Monday, August 24, 2009

“I’m afraid of Obama!” – woman at a town hall meeting on health-care reform
I have no opinion on H.R. 3200. Mainly because I haven’t read it.

Pardon my presumption, but chances are beyond excellent that you haven’t, either. The PDF file of the bill, otherwise known as the America’s Affordable Health Choices Act of 2009, clocks in at 1,017 pages of often-dense legalese and jargon. I’d like to read it, but I’d also like to have a life, and the two are incompatible.

So excuse me, beg pardon, but it would be really valuable to hear an explanation of the bill by those who presumably have read it, followed by vigorous questioning. Instead, the circus has come to town.

I refer, of course, to the chaos that has erupted at town hall meetings as Democratic lawmakers try to sell the bill. The New York Times reports shouting matches, fistfights, threats, injuries and arrests. Georgia Congressman David Scott says he’s had death threats and a visit from vandals who painted a swastika outside his office.

If you wonder what the Nazis have to do with this, join the club. It’s an incoherent protest and where there is incoherence, naturally, there is Sarah Palin. The former governor of Alaska weighed in on Facebook with a claim that Democrats were proposing a “downright evil” system in which the fate of the elderly and the disabled would be determined by “death panels.”

She said she was referring to Sec. 1233 of the bill, so I read it. It would allow your doctor to regularly consult with you on the need for a living will and advanced care directives, i.e., decide ahead of time if you’d want to be kept alive in a persistent vegetative state. This may or may not be a good idea but it’s hardly “downright evil” and it bears no resemblance to the image Palin conjures: Granny forced to justify her continued existence before a panel of men in black hoods.

Conservatives would have you believe this pandemonium is spontaneous. Truth is, it’s about as spontaneous as a shuttle launch. The Times account tells us a banner appeared on the Web site of Fox News host Sean Hannity inviting people to “Become a part of the mob!” A group calling itself Tea Party Patriots advises its members to pack the hall and “yell out.” This is manufactured outrage.

And that’s fine. If people choose to become part of a synchronized protest, they have every right to. Nor is there anything wrong with dissent. As many of us pointed out when George W. Bush’s enablers sought to silence his critics, dissent is patriotic.

But shouting down those who disagree with you is not. Neither is threatening, shoving, hitting, painting swastikas or otherwise rendering reasoned debate impossible. That’s not love of country, it’s not dissent, it’s not even civilized. It’s boorish, oafish and crude, the rantings of people panicked beyond reason.

In other words, conservatives. OK, not all of them. But too many of them? Definitely.
By now, it has become reflex, this instinct of theirs to manipulate the debate and muddy the waters by stoking people’s primal fears, whether of gays, Muslims, Hispanics or now, health care reform. “I’m afraid of Obama!” screams a woman. And doesn’t that just say it all? Doesn’t that speak volumes about the intellectual bankruptcy and decayed moral authority of the political right? With apologies to Franklin Roosevelt, the only thing they have to sell is fear itself.

And no, that’s not patriotism. It is the cynical behavior of people who have little faith in their ability to win the debate. So they pick a fight and try to win that instead.

Leonard Pitts is a columnist for the Miami Herald, 1 Herald Plaza, Miami, Fla., 33132. Readers may contact him via e-mail at lpitts@miamiherald.com.

By using this website’s user-contribution features, including comments, photo galleries, or any other feature, you agree to abide by the terms of use. Please read this agreement in its entirety because it contains useful information that will help you better understand the rules and general "good manners" that are expected when contributing content to this website.

  • mikea0815

    Mr. Pitts, as usual is wrong, and out of touch with what Americans are thinking. His quote about a woman being afraid of Obama is written in a way to make us think Americans are afraid of him because he is black, and not because of his radical ideas. The truth is, white America elected him, along with black America and hispanic America and female America, gay America, and other factions. But that is exactly why we SHOULD fear Obama. His wish to factionalize the country, along with his Marxist tendencies. If those who oppose H.R. 3200 are so organized, why is it that they have hand written signs and the SEIU, ACORN, et.al. all have mass produced signs? Mr. Pitts wants us to see our country through the eyes of a man who believes that race is an integral part of American thinking. It is not. In what other society on earth is there “affirmative action?” No, this country has not always been equal in its treatment of other races, but that was in another time and with a much different mindset than exists today. What Americans ARE tired of is constantly being assaulted about being racist. Give it a rest Leonard

  • Username75

    Sounds like a spoiled child, when Your wrong, shout you are right.
    when You don’t know bluff.
    but above all win, as You know nothing…BUT
    You are right because You are right,
    Others have no RIGHT to be Right
    Only you do.
    When I was a child I was made fun of each day at school
    by those kind of People.
    The Majority of Americans Voted for President Obama
    to discount them as unworthy of the Vote is
    Sheer foolishness
    as foolish as pointing at someone else to
    Hide your own shortcomings.

Editor's Picks